Tuesday, December 20, 2011

Celebrating Communities, the Holidays, and You


Dear Friend,

Every day, we at Calvert Foundation hear stories that give us hope for a brighter future. Every day, people use capital from our investors and donors to start new businesses, build affordable homes and make their communities better. Every day, new investors buy the Community Investment Note and align their investments with their values, earning social returns along with financial returns.

We also see the issues of economic disparity and uncertainty on the front page every day. Since 1995, Calvert Foundation has been working to create opportunities for hard-working people in the U.S. and around the world so they can create better lives for themselves, their families, and their communities. As we count our blessings this year, we ask you to make a donation to Calvert Foundation. As a nonprofit, we rely on donations to leverage investor capital and transform lives.

We’re proud of our impact:
  • $104 million to help create jobs and grow businesses
  • $65 million to ensure that families have decent affordable homes
  • $30 million for community facilities, like charter schools, health care centers and arts facilities
  • $4 million for fair trade and sustainable agriculture
A few highlights from 2011:
As we look forward to 2012 and all of the opportunities a new year represents, we wanted to take a moment to thank you. It is your engagement, compassion and interest that make our work possible. This holiday season, we at Calvert Foundation send our best wishes to you, your families, and friends.

Lisa Hall
President and CEO, Calvert Foundation

Monday, December 12, 2011

Building Trust Through Information

This post, by Christina Conrad Cuenca, Manager, Lending and Advisory Services, was originally published on November 2, 2011, in the Microplace blog. 

Impact investing has been getting a lot of great publicity lately, but that doesn't necessarily translate into comfort for investors. Knowledge and information, on the other hand, do. Which is one of many reasons we are so glad to be a part of the Global Impact Investing Rating System, or GIIRS, an independent third party that assesses the social and environmental impact of companies and investment funds.

GIIRS is a project of B Lab, one of our borrowers, and was announced officially in September at the Clinton Global Initiative meeting in New York.

Calvert Foundation is one of the “15 Pioneer Investors” who have declared a preference for GIIRS-rated funds and companies in their impact investing decision process. Furthermore, our participation in this is a signal to more mainstream institutions and investors that credible metrics on impact are necessary for impact investing to succeed.

As the head of Calvert Foundation's risk management team, I take a special interest in encouraging efforts such as GIIRS. One of the great challenges we face in evaluating investment opportunities is a lack of standard metrics across sectors (such as affordable housing and microfinance) and organizational models (such as social enterprises and co-operatives). While we have been successful at navigating our way through these challenges - often by creating our own metrics and screens - the industry as a whole has a better chance to grow and thrive if there is a third-party rating system that investors can turn to for information and comparison.

GIIRS, which has an aggressive five-year plan to provide ratings for more than 2,500 companies and over 350 funds, typically rates venture capital and private equity funds and for-profit companies. Because of this, most of the organizations we invest in wouldn't qualify yet - and neither (as a 501c3) would we. Because of Calvert Foundation's complex model, we often don't quite fit into a defined model, but we are working with GIIRS and the industry at large to change this, one step at a time.

Monday, November 28, 2011

CDFIs: Americans Investing in Americans

By Noelle St. Clair, Investor Relations Associate


Noelle St. Clair
I recently traveled to Minneapolis for the 2011 Opportunity Finance Network conference with Calvert Foundation Marketing Manager, Carrie Hutchison. Since Carrie and I have traveled together quite a bit lately, I know never to get between her and her Starbucks! To someone whose knowledge of caffeinated beverages is pretty much limited to plain coffee or tea, trying to decipher the intricate orders at Starbucks feels like a quasi-foreign experience for me. I did, however, stop into my local Starbucks before the trip to pick up my Create Jobs for USA wristband.

The proceeds from the sale of these wristbands will be donated to Opportunity Finance Network (OFN). Calvert Foundation is a proud member of OFN, the national network of Community Development Financial Institutions or “CDFIs.” Starbucks recognized the good work CDFIs have been doing, delivering affordable capital to low-income and disadvantaged communities around the country, but also realized that the average person has no idea what a CDFI is or what it does. Through the Create Jobs for USA campaign, Starbucks is not only providing funding to OFN and CDFIs, but also helping the industry to receive national recognition. By “buying” and wearing these wristbands, people across the nation are creating jobs for Americans, while simultaneously raising awareness of CDFIs.

Americans, including me, are often quick to complain about the problems in our country. When a solution to a problem becomes apparent, it is empowering to become part of that solution. This is one of the reasons I enjoy working at Calvert Foundation so much. Calvert Foundation is lending to more than 60 CDFIs that are creating jobs in America. More importantly, Calvert Foundation is funded by individual investors looking to become part of the solution to some of our country’s most pressing problems. Americans helping Americans, people investing in people – this is what Calvert Foundation does and this is what OFN and Starbucks are doing with the Create Jobs for USA campaign.

There was definitely a buzz at the OFN conference about the campaign and the partnership with Starbucks. Adam Brotman, VP of Digital Ventures for Starbucks, spoke at the conference, specifically about Starbucks’ commitment to communities and their efforts outside of the new campaign. Adam had an impressive list, including the fact that Starbucks has been an investor in the Calvert Foundation Community Investment Note for almost 10 years. We are appreciative of the support that Starbucks has given and continues to provide for organizations doing the type of work that we do. Personally, I was very impressed by Starbucks and although I don’t think I’ll ever have a VIP Gold discount card like my caffeinated friend Carrie, I just might have to stop in a bit more frequently for a Tall Soy Sugar Free Cinnamon Dolce Latte!

Learn more about CDFIs by watching this great video created by Citi Foundation and OFN!

Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Water and Sanitation: A Quadruple Bottom Line Investment

By Anthony Randazzo, CFA, Senior Investment Officer

Something ironic happened to me the day before I spoke on a Water and Sanitation panel at the Impact Investing Summit in Washington, D.C.

I entered the kitchen at 6:30 in the morning to make my first dose of coffee, but when I reached for the faucet to fill up the kettle, no water came out - just an annoying hissing sound. A water main had burst in the middle of the night, knocking out the water supply in our entire neighborhood.

If you are like me, then you believe things happen to you for a reason. So, it occurred to me as I stood in my kitchen wondering how I was going to get ready for work that perhaps I was meant to feel solidarity that morning with the 884 million people in the developing world who live without clean water every day. We take clean water for granted, so what better way to prepare a heartfelt presentation on water than to live without it for a day?

Personal water deprivations aside, the Impact Investing Summit provided me an opportunity to interact with commercial and institutional investors from across the financial spectrum to discuss how to use investment to alleviate poverty and address environmental issues. The panel discussion on Water and Sanitation was well received and I, along with co-panelists Rich Thorsten from Water.org and D. Paul Sathianathan, of Guardian, fielded questions about what we do, how our organizations tackle the water and sanitation scarcity issue and why we have chosen to work in this space.

To date, the Calvert Foundation has invested approximately $4 million in social impact investments for improved water and sanitation. Most of this has been indirect, through loans to financial intermediaries that have invested in water and sanitation, but we also have a direct investment in E-Healthpoint, a social enterprise that provides clean water and affordable healthcare in rural India. Why is Calvert Foundation interested in this sector? There are two main reasons.

A woman selling drinking water on the 
streets of Mumbai in India. Proof that water can
 generate income for the working poor. 
Photo by Anthony Randazzo
A “quadruple bottom line”

For one, if done right, investing in water and sanitation can be a rewarding proposition. We have all heard of companies that generate a “double bottom line” i.e. that generate both financial returns and a “social” return (i.e. reduce poverty). However, water can achieve at least four types of impact, producing what I like to call a “quadruple bottom line.”

  • It can have a direct impact on health. Waterborne diseases are a major cause of diarrhea and other illnesses that kill poor people in developing countries. It is estimated that 1.5 million children under the age of five die every year as a result of water and sanitation-related diseases.
  • It can have a gender impact. Women and girls shoulder 72% of the burden for collecting water for the household. By freeing up their time, women can live more productive lives and girls can spend more time in school. 
  • It can have a positive economic impact. Clean water can generate revenue for the family if it is sold or used to maintain a small business. It can also translate into increased savings if better health means higher productivity or less money spent on healthcare. 
  • Finally, water can have a conflict resolution impact. We live in a world where countries enter into conflict over scarce resources. It is not inconceivable that countries will one day fight over water. By investing in clean water today, we can reduce the likelihood that conflicts over water will happen tomorrow. Better water resource management can also improve food security. 
Social and Environmental Impact

The other reason why Calvert Foundation is interested in water and sanitation is because our investors are increasingly interested in achieving both a social return on their investment as well as an environmental impact. However, finding investments that reduce poverty, solve environmental problems, and produce a stable return can be challenging.

We need to keep in mind that there are 2.6 billion people without access to improved sanitation in addition to the 880 million without clean water. Those are large numbers, so you need to harness the private sector to find a solution to these problems. The failure of governments to provide these public services in the developing world has meant that the private sector has had to step in to try to fill the void with “off-grid” solutions. In fact, there are many simple, affordable off-grid solutions available to provide clean water and improved sanitation at the base of the economic pyramid. These range from household water purification systems, to rainwater harvesters, to simple pit latrines.

However, finding the right business model that can deliver such products and services at scale and at an affordable price can be a challenge. There are many organizations out there focused on addressing the water and sanitation issue, but in my experience, most are donor-dependent and few are set up to harness the private sector in a sustainable, scalable manner. The carbon-offset market might provide an answer, since off-grid water purification provides an alternative to boiling, but it remains to be seen if this additional revenue can be tapped as successfully by the water sector as it has by the renewable energy sector. It may be that social enterprises in the water and sanitation sector are today where microfinance institutions were 15 years ago, i.e. still reliant on donor funding to absorb start-up costs and stimulate private investment.

In September of 2010, the Human Rights Council recognized the right to water and sanitation as legally binding under international law. This will help to underscore the responsibility of governments to deliver water and sanitation to their citizens, but it will take time and resources for the public sector to bridge the gap. For this reason, we have to continue to find market-led solutions to the problem since charity alone will not get us there.

Moreover, we all need to be reminded that water is a scarce resource, and not having it for a day will make you realize (as I did) that you can get ready for work with very small quantities of water (from my tea kettle and Brita water filter).

Thursday, October 13, 2011

Grateful Reflections on the Big Easy

By Art Stevens, Vice President, Sales and Marketing

I usually start looking forward to the next SRI in the Rockies conference about three days after the last one ends, and I’ve caught up on some sleep. I had to add a little extra recovery time after this year’s event in New Orleans, but my anticipation for 2012 is already building.  SRI in the Rockies may have strayed geographically from its mountain roots, but even after 22 years, its soul is firmly grounded.

Each year this event brings together hundreds of friends to celebrate our shared commitment to an economic system that balances the needs of the one with the needs of the many, creating opportunity while pursuing justice. And each year I am thrilled to meet dozens of people new to the conference (and sometime to the industry) who bring with them new energy and fresh perspectives. Most of all I get to spend time with our amazing team.

In one moment SRI in the Rockies provides a great view of the amazing progress we have made in the past two decades, a perspective easily lost in our day-to-day work. The next moment it challenges us to take an unblinking look at where we are - even to get a little ticked off - before sending us back into the arena. Like a true friend, the conference is a forum for asking the tough questions that challenge us to be better, and also a place to share a dance and remember that we are all in this together.

This year, Noelle St. Clair (Investor Relations Associate at Calvert Foundation and an SRI-R first-timer) and I had the further privilege of seeing the real-life results of our investors’ efforts. We visited the Treme neighborhood and met Mr. Brumfeld, a 63-year-old wheelchair-bound man. He spent the night Katrina hit on a bridge with hundreds of others, then five days in the Convention Center, before being relocated to another state for more than three years. My first reaction to stories like his is still disbelief that this can happen in America.

Thanks to the support of our advisors and investors, and the great work of Enterprise, our partner in the field, Mr.Brumfeld is now back in his familiar neighborhood, in a healthy, secure, and fully accessible apartment. His smile tells the story more effectively than any words I can compose, which is why we are excited to be producing a video to share his story along with other great successes from our partners in New Orleans like Hope Enterprise Corporation.

Friday, September 30, 2011

Let’s “Travel Down this Road Together”

By Lisa Hall, President & CEO of Calvert Foundation

I was honored to participate last week as a speaker on a panel about the racial wealth gap in this country at the Congressional Black Caucus Foundation’s annual conference. The energy was amazing, and I was so glad to bring the message of impact investing to such a diverse and dynamic audience.

The highlight of the conference was, of course, President Barack Obama’s remarks at the event’s Annual Phoenix Awards Dinner. In his address to “the conscience of the Congress,” President Obama spoke about the importance of faith in our collective quest to move economic and social justice forward.

One of the reasons I’m so excited to be leading Calvert Foundation is because I believe so deeply and personally in this work that we do, connecting investors to social causes. I feel in many ways that I have always been sitting at this intersection of finance and doing good. My father was a social worker and activist in the civil rights movement, my mother a life-long school teacher and public servant. My personal story is one of a little girl from Baltimore whose parents and extended family put no limits on how much I could accomplish in this lifetime. And I believe there is no limit on what we can accomplish as a country if we collectively put our minds and our hearts to it.

During the past few years, our economy has suffered greatly and yet the wealth is building at the top. The statistics are staggering. According to a recent Pew Research study, the median wealth of white households at $113,149 is 20 times that of black households at $5,677 and 18 times that of Hispanic households at $6,325. This staggering gap requires immediate action.

Through impact investment, we create a virtuous circle of empowerment, opportunity, and respect by connecting investors to underserved individuals and communities. I’d like to point out here that making opportunity available to all Americans doesn’t have to be a divisive issue. It’s a fact that some of the most successful community development tools, such as the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit and the New Markets Tax Credit, have been bi-partisan efforts supported by both Republicans and Democrats in the past.

Impact investing fits as a tool for economic growth that has no color – neither Red nor Blue. And I’m so glad our industry is finally getting some traction in the political sphere. I was excited to hear that Jonathan Greenblatt, a long time social entrepreneur and impact investing leader, was recently appointed to work with Melody Barnes, the head of Obama’s Domestic Policy Council. Jonathan will head the White House’s Office of Social Innovation and Civic Engagement where he will lead the Administration’s efforts to grow the Impact Economy.

I want more people – from all communities – to be involved in the Impact Economy. Every investor can be part of the solution to closing the wealth gap. We need to act. I believe as President Obama said in his speech last Saturday and as I would like to reiterate on behalf of Calvert Foundation and the impact investing industry:

“We have to do more to put people to work right now. We’ve got to make that everyone in this country gets a fair shake, and a fair shot, and a chance to get ahead. And I know we won’t get where we need to go if we don’t travel down this road together.”

Sunday, August 21, 2011

Fortune Favors the Bold

By Lisa Hall, Calvert Foundation's President & CEO

Last month I was honored to participate in the inaugural Rockefeller Foundation Innovation Forum in the Chelsea Arts District of Manhattan along with one hundred other leaders in the social and private sector. It was a thought provoking event in a unique setting – Center 548 – an industrial warehouse space transformed into a conference center. The main entrance features a massive freight elevator that transported attendees to the second floor, where a large video screen showed an African women making her journey to bring water from a distant source to her home. It was a striking juxtaposition to the short distance we travelled from the elevator to a table overflowing with bottled water. 

The Forum focused on water security, food security, and economic security in American cities, and encouraged revolutionary thinking on solutions to these problems. The forum began with an extraordinary panel moderated by Dr. Judith Rodin, the President of Rockefeller Foundation, who previously made history at my alma mater, the University of Pennsylvania, as the first permanent female president of an Ivy League university. Distinguished panelists included Dr. Paul Farmer of Harvard University and founder of the world renowned international development organization, Partners in Health (PIH), and Nobel Prize winner Muhammad Yunus, who was an early advocate for – and some would say the inventor of – microfinance and founder of Grameen Bank.

Their legendary accomplishments inspired me to think about the next chapter for Calvert Foundation and what innovation means in impact investment. We are currently engaged in a major strategic planning effort with the assistance of Monitor Institute to envision and plan for the future and ensure success in our next 15 years. As I think about new ideas for Calvert Foundation, I wonder what would be possible if we could build out options to popularize the use of self-directed IRAs for impact investments. Or if we could create an investment product that allowed non-profits with earned revenue models to raise money from individuals, something similar to equity that would provide these non-profits with sorely needed growth capital. Another possibility? What about syndicating Low Income Housing Tax Credits or New Markets Tax Credits for individual investors?

With enough grant support, these could become more than just ideas. I’ve heard from many sources that workers are investing less in their 401k accounts – not only because they are they getting lower returns than they did historically, but also because they have no connection to their investments. Products like Calvert Foundation’s Community Investment Note and RSF’s Social Investment Fund allow investors to be connected to communities through programs like the California FreshWorks Fund, which is financing distribution of fresh, healthy food to “food deserts” in low-income neighborhoods. Calvert Foundation has also helped other non-profits – such as affordable housing group Enterprise Community Partners and international microfinance organization Oikocredit – offer investment notes to their respective stakeholders. We are proud of our past innovations at Calvert Social Investment Foundation and we are poised to do more and take bigger risks in collaboration with others. 

One of my favorite lines originates from the ancient Roman play Aneid by Virgil. It is often quoted and was recently referenced by Cheryl Sandberg, COO of Facebook, in her commencement address to the 2011 class of Barnard. In her speech Sandberg challenged the graduating women to take more chances personally and professionally – to do those things they would do “if they were not afraid.” After reading the transcript of Sandberg’s speech a few weeks ago, I haven’t been able to get the words out of my head: “Fortune favors the bold.” This quote resonated with me as I sat last month in the audience at the Innovation Forum and listened throughout the day.

I think funders should be putting larger, longer-term dollars toward mountain-moving efforts, not just the new start-up idea. In other words, I think they should be making bigger bets. “Bet” might seem like a bad word in the philanthropic/nonprofit sector since “betting” implies risk. But that is exactly why I’m using it. You might lose, sure. But you also might win big and watch a grant leveraged over and over to help thousands of people. For example, the $50 million in net assets that the Ford Foundation gave to Self-Help in the late 90's has been truly transformative.

This is not to say that smaller, shorter-term grants don’t have their place. They certainly do – Calvert Foundation could never have gotten off the ground if the great staff at the MacArthur Foundation didn’t bet on us years ago. But as government retracts and underserved communities are more in need than ever, there is a real opportunity to broaden impact. This is about more than the money – it’s about leadership and sending a signal to the larger philanthropic world about the importance of investing in big ideas and influential players.

Aiming high, taking risk and being innovative is also about more than the money – it’s about leadership and encouraging the larger philanthropic and impact investing community, to invest in big ideas and influential leaders. When thinking about risk, I believe we should be asking ourselves, “What is the risk of NOT taking risk?”